If you’re a fan of classic oatmeal cream pies and can’t get enough of pumpkin spice, these pumpkin oatmeal cream pies are your next must-try bake! Start by baking a batch of soft pumpkin oatmeal cookies—no dough chilling needed. Then, sandwich them together with a tangy, spiced cream cheese filling to create irresistible oatmeal cream pies bursting with cozy fall flavors.
While there is so much to love about fall—cooler temps, colorful leaves, Halloween fun—obviously the best part about this time of year is the BAKING.
Today’s pumpkin sandwich cookie recipe is a new one to add to your list of must-try fall recipes. I know that list is probably quite long… but trust me, this one is worthy of a place on it!
We tested a few versions of the recipe below, and learned some key success tips along the way. Happy to share:
1. Blot the pumpkin. Pumpkin puree is a considerably wet ingredient (it’s 90% water), which is a good thing for adding moisture to cakes, pumpkin muffins, and pumpkin bread. But it poses a problem when we’re trying to make dense, chewy oatmeal cookies. More moisture = cakier cookies.
To prevent overly cakey cookies, blot some moisture out of the pumpkin using paper towels. You’ll start with 1 cup of pumpkin puree (about 225–240g); after blotting, you should end up with about 3/4 cup (170g).
2. Use only an egg yolk. Pumpkin acts kind of like an egg in cookie dough, which I learned when testing pumpkin chocolate chip cookies back in 2013 (that is an egg-free recipe). Testing pumpkin oatmeal cookies, however, proved that an egg—or at least part of an egg—is necessary. The cookies were a little dry and crumbly without it because of the oats in the dough. Use just 1 large egg yolk here, because that little extra bit of fat makes a difference.
3. Use a cookie scoop. I strongly recommend using a medium cookie scoop. Why? First, because the cookies need to all be roughly equal in size (about a scant 1 and 1/2 Tablespoons) to sandwich together. And second, because this dough is very sticky and would be much too difficult to roll with your hands. A cookie scoop scrapes the dough out cleanly and drops a perfectly sized lump of dough onto the baking sheet every time.
If you do not have a cookie scoop, drop a heaping Tablespoon (about 25–30g) of dough for each cookie onto the lined baking sheet.
You should get about 36–40 cookies out of this dough, so you’ll end up with 18–20 sandwiches.
4. Flatten out the cookies slightly before baking. You can use the back of a spoon for this. These cookies don’t expand much in the oven, and pressing them down first encourages spreading. The result? Chewier, flatter cookies just right for sandwiching together to make a pumpkin oatmeal cream pie.
5. Spoon the edges. If your cookies are spreading too much or unevenly, remove them from the oven and use a spoon to lightly push any wonky edges back in towards the center, to reshape into circles. (I do this with chocolate chip cookies.) Return to the oven to continue baking. You can repeat this trick again, if needed, after baking.
Make the filling while you wait for the cookies to cool. You need cream cheese and confectioners’ sugar, plus a few ingredients that you used for the cookie dough, too: butter, vanilla, pumpkin pie spice, and salt.
The filling required a bit of testing. I kept reducing the sugar, to really help the pumpkin spice and cream cheese flavors stand out. However, the more confectioners’ sugar you reduce, the thinner the filling becomes. What you see here is an ideal consistency, with just enough sweetness.
You can use a pastry bag + tip and pipe the filling, or simply spread it on with a knife or icing spatula. If you want to pipe it and do not have a piping tip and pastry bag, use a regular zip-top plastic bag and snip off 1 corner. Pipe or spread the frosting onto the bottoms of half the cookies, then sandwich with the remaining cookies. I used Wilton 2A tip to pipe.
These soft and chewy pumpkin oatmeal cookies would also make wonderful ice cream cookie sandwiches! Simply swap the cream cheese filling for vanilla or pumpkin ice cream, and follow the instructions for sandwiching the cookies with softened ice cream, wrapping, and freezing from my cookie ice cream sandwich recipe.
Soft and chewy pumpkin oatmeal cookies are sandwiched with tangy-sweet and spiced cream cheese filling. To ensure the best results, review my success tips above before beginning.
