I make this Costco-style creamy Italian salad when I want the big-bowl crunch of a deli salad without buying a whole prepared tray. It is mostly chopping and tossing, but the order matters more than people think. If I drown the croutons too early, they lose the rough, garlicky crunch that makes the salad fun.
My best version starts with cold romaine, thin ribbons of cabbage, plenty of Italian cheese, and just enough creamy Italian dressing to coat instead of puddle. I add the croutons last, then serve right away. It is a simple salad, but when the vegetables are crisp and the dressing is balanced, it tastes like the kind of side I keep going back to with my fork.
I also like that it scales.
Why I like this salad
- It gives me the creamy-crunchy feel of a chopped restaurant salad with only a few ingredients.
- Romaine brings juicy crunch, while red and green cabbage hold up longer than delicate greens.
- Garlic croutons add seasoning as well as texture, so the salad does not taste flat.
- Italian cheeses make it feel generous without needing a long list of add-ins.
- I can serve it as a side or add protein and call it lunch.
- The components can be prepped ahead if I keep the dressing and croutons separate.
What you need and how I treat each ingredient
- Romaine lettuce, 3 cups chopped.I wash it, dry it very well, and chop it into bite-size pieces. Wet lettuce thins the dressing and makes the bowl soggy.
- Garlic croutons, 2 cups.I keep them whole unless they are huge. Broken croutons sink to the bottom and turn soft faster.
- Italian cheeses, 2 cups.A shredded Italian blend is easy. If I grate my own, I use mozzarella for meltiness and parmesan for sharper flavor.
- Red cabbage, 2 cups thinly sliced.I slice it as thin as I can because thick cabbage pieces feel bulky in a creamy salad.
- Green cabbage, 2 cups thinly sliced.It adds crunch and stretches the salad so the romaine is not doing all the work.
- Creamy Italian dressing.The source does not give an amount, so I add it gradually and stop when every leaf is lightly coated. I would rather set extra dressing on the table than overdo the bowl.
How I make it
Step 1 — Chill the bowl and dry the greens
If I have time, I put the serving bowl in the refrigerator while I prep. I wash the romaine, spin it dry, and pat the cabbage with a towel if it looks damp. Creamy dressing clings better to dry vegetables.
Step 2 — Build the crunchy base
I add the thinly sliced green cabbage, red cabbage, and chopped romaine to the bowl. I toss them with my hands first so the colors are evenly mixed before any dressing goes in. This keeps one person from getting a plate of mostly cabbage.
Step 3 — Add cheese and dressing
I sprinkle in the 2 cups Italian cheeses and spoon creamy Italian dressing around the outside of the bowl. Then I toss from the bottom up. I add more dressing only if the salad still looks dry; I want shine, not soup.
Step 4 — Finish with croutons
The 2 cups garlic croutons go in right before serving. I toss twice, gently, and stop. If I am taking the salad somewhere, I pack the croutons in a separate bag and add them at the table.
Tips from my kitchen
- Slice cabbage thin.Thin cabbage feels crisp; thick cabbage feels like work.
- Dry everything.Water is the fastest way to make creamy dressing taste weak.
- Dress in stages.I start with less dressing than I think I need and add more after tossing.
- Croutons last.Even sturdy garlic croutons soften if they sit in dressing too long.
- Use a bigger bowl than seems necessary.Tossing is cleaner and the cheese distributes better.
Variations I have actually tried
- Grilled chicken salad:I add sliced grilled chicken and serve it as a main dish. The creamy dressing works well with smoky chicken.
- Pizza-night version:I add sliced pepperoncini and a handful of cherry tomatoes for a sharper, pizzeria-style bowl.
- Lower-carb bowl:I use fewer croutons and add extra cabbage. I still keep some croutons because the garlic crunch is the point for me.
- Vegetarian antipasto:I add olives, roasted red peppers, and chickpeas. It becomes heartier without needing meat.
- Lighter dressing:I cut the creamy Italian dressing with a spoonful of plain Greek yogurt and a splash of vinegar when I want more tang.
Make-ahead notes
I prep the romaine and cabbage up to 2 days ahead and store them in separate containers lined with paper towels. The cheese can be measured ahead, too. I do not combine everything with dressing until close to serving because dressed romaine wilts.
Leftover dressed salad is still edible the next day, but it loses the snap. If I know I will have leftovers, I dress only the portion I plan to serve and keep the rest plain.
What I serve it with
This is the salad I put next to lasagna, baked ziti, pizza, grilled sausages, or a simple roast chicken. It also makes a good lunch base with tuna, chicken, or white beans on top. I like something warm and salty beside it because the salad is cold, creamy, and crunchy.
Frequently asked questions
How much creamy Italian dressing should I use?
The source does not list a measurement, so I add it slowly. For 10 servings, I usually start with about 1/2 cup, toss, and add more by the spoonful if needed. The vegetables should be coated but not dripping.
Can I make it vegan?
Yes. I use plant-based creamy Italian dressing, skip the cheese or use a dairy-free Italian-style shred, and check that the croutons do not contain dairy.
Can I make this salad ahead for a party?
I prep the vegetables, cheese, dressing, and croutons separately. About 10 minutes before serving, I toss the vegetables and cheese with dressing, then add croutons last.
What if I do not like cabbage?
I use more romaine and add chopped cucumbers for crunch. The salad will be softer and will not hold as long, but the flavor still lands in the same creamy Italian lane.
How do I keep croutons crunchy?
I keep them separate until the final toss. If the salad sits on a buffet, I reserve a handful and sprinkle them over the top halfway through serving.
If you make this salad, tell me what you added to the bowl; I am always curious about the extra crunchy bits.
One small thing I do before serving is taste one dressed cabbage strand, not just a romaine leaf. Cabbage needs a little more seasoning to taste finished, and that tiny bite tells me whether I need another spoonful of dressing, a crack of pepper, or a pinch of parmesan. It is a plain check, but it saves the whole bowl from tasting underdressed underneath the croutons.
If I am serving this with something salty like pizza, I keep the dressing lighter. If the salad is the main lunch, I dress it a little more generously and add protein. That adjustment keeps the same six ingredients from feeling like the same salad every time.
Costco creamy Italian salad
Description
A crunchy Costco-style creamy Italian salad with romaine, red cabbage, green cabbage, Italian cheeses, garlic croutons, and creamy dressing. I toss it in stages so the greens stay crisp.
Ingredients You’ll Need
Instructions
- Wash and dry the romaine well, thinly slice the red and green cabbage, and chill the serving bowl if time allows.
- Add the green cabbage, red cabbage, and chopped romaine to a large bowl; toss with your hands so the vegetables are evenly mixed.
- Sprinkle in the Italian cheeses, add creamy Italian dressing gradually, and toss from the bottom up until the vegetables are lightly coated.
- Add the garlic croutons right before serving, toss gently once or twice, and serve in individual bowls or plates.
Nutrition Facts
Servings 10
- Iron 0.0 mg
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your daily value may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.
Note
Dry the greens. Water thins the dressing and makes the salad bland.
Dress gradually. I add less than I think I need, toss, then add more by the spoonful.
Add croutons last. They stay crunchy only if they avoid a long soak.
Prep ahead in parts. Keep vegetables, cheese, dressing, and croutons separate until serving.
Frequently Asked Questions
The source does not list an amount, so I add it gradually. Start around 1/2 cup for the full bowl, toss, and add more only if needed.
Yes. Use plant-based creamy Italian dressing, dairy-free cheese or no cheese, and croutons made without dairy.
I prep the vegetables and cheese ahead, but I wait to add dressing and croutons until close to serving.
Yes. I like grilled chicken, tuna, chickpeas, or white beans on top when I want it to become lunch.
Dressed leftovers soften by the next day. For better leftovers, store the undressed salad separately from dressing and croutons.
